Christmas cookie recipe: Buckeyes

One time when it is particularly nice to live within walking distance of a working farm is when you run out of eggs midway through a Christmas-cookie baking marathon.  Mrs. L. just keeps the eggs on the porch, no need to knock dear, just drop your cash in the box and take however many you need…

My mother and grandmother, and who knows, probably even many of my great grandmothers before them, were avid Christmas cookie bakers. My mother and grandmother always made candy cane cookies, Russian tea cakes, gingerbread men, press cookies, goodie bars, and some Polish cookie whose name I can’t remember made with nuts and a honey syrup.

Of course, nearly everyone else’s mother and grandmother made lots of Christmas cookies too back when I was a young girl, and one of my favorite things about Christmas was exchanging plates of homemade treats with friends and neighbors and seeing what other kids’ moms made for Christmas. Our neighbors from the time we moved to Caledonia when I was 13 were the Prices, and Mrs. Price introduced us to a new Christmas cookie, Church Windows, which are made with colored mini marshmallows that are supposed to resemble church stained glass windows. I made these for the first time last year, but my family didn’t much like them.

A few years ago, one of my co-workers gave me a plate of cookies that included a heavenly little cookie she called “buckeyes” because they look like the nuts dropped from the Buckeye tree. I’d never heard of them or tried them, but it turns out they are not uncommon at Christmas. I tried making them the next year, and my family loved them, so they’ve become a staple at our house at the holidays. Here is my recipe to make the ones you see below beside the mini pumpkin-cranberry loaves, but if you don’t like mine, there are lots of other versions of this same recipe available online:

Buckeyes and Pumpkin Bread

My buckeyes and pumpkin-cranberry bread.

Sunshine’s Christmas Buckeyes

  • 3 c crunchy peanut butter (I use the natural kind without hydrogenated oils but any kind will work)
  • 2 c unsalted butter at room temperature
  • 1 t vanilla
  • 12 c powdered sugar
  • 8 c semi-sweet chocolate chips


1. In a very large mixing bowl, cream together the softened butter and peanut butter. Beat in the vanilla, then the powdered sugar one cup at a time.

2. Roll into one-inch balls and place on waxed paper to chill. This recipe makes a LOT of cookies, so what I do is use a plastic storage bin and layer the cookie balls in it between layers of waxed paper, snap the lid on tight, then put it in our unheated garage to chill overnight. If you cut this recipe in half, you could probably just layer the cookies on waxed paper on a cookie sheet and put them in the refrigerator. But trust me, you’re going to want the full recipe.

3. When chilled, melt 2-4 cups of the chocolate chips in a class bowl on medium power in 45 second intervals, stirring in between, until melted. You’ll melt more as you need it.

4. Stick a toothpick into each chilled cookie ball and dip into melted chocolate, coating the bottom and sides. Place on waxed paper on cookie sheets to cool. When the chocolate has hardened, layer the buckeyes between sheets of waxed paper in a container with a lid and store in the refrigerator or freezer.

While you are busy in the kitchen, have a listen to one of my favorite versions of “What Child is This?”


7 thoughts on “Christmas cookie recipe: Buckeyes

  1. It’s probably a factor of my age, but I LOVE peaceful evenings at home with my family. I mean, it’s just truly bliss. We were rushing about all day, baking and cleaning and taking kids places and then it was time to dress for church. After church we had to run around and give cards and boxes of homemade cookies to various people, and then we came home and I threw together a light dinner (Laura Wood would not have approved of the prewashed, pretrimmed green beans I used 🙂 but I swear I don’t do that very often!).

    The kids are now watching a Christmas movie on the old TV/DVD player in the family room and I’ve stretched out on the couch for the first time in I don’t know how long. I’m too lazy to get up and light a fire in the fireplace (Phil would do it but he’s out in his workshop varnishing picture frames he made from wood he salvaged of his late father’s machine shop floor), but I lit some candles.

    It’s blurry because I’m using an iPad, but you can kind of see the tree up in the loft reflected in the mirror above the fireplace. Anyway, it’s cozy and peaceful and nearly everyone I love best is here. I can’t imagine fulfillment in some old job being superior to this, much as I like my job.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Yoda,
    This is the Sunshine that you were looking for. It could be that she does not know that you are closely affiliated with Farm Boy.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s